Wegen Abgeordneten-Pauschale: Ein Drittel des Gehalts steuerfrei?

1. Die Streitfrage

Xxxxxxxx Xxx xxxx xxxx: Xxx xxxx xx Xxxxxx xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxx Xxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx xxx xxx xxxxx xx xxxxxxxx

Xxxx xxx "xxxxxxx" Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx xxx xxxx xxx x.xxx XXX xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx, xxxx xx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxx. Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxx xx.xxx XXX xxxxxx, xxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxx. Xx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxx, xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxx xxx.xxx XXX xxxxxxxxxx. Xxxxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx, xxxx xxxx xxxxx

XXXXXXX: Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx xxx x.x.xxxx xxxxxxxxx x.xxx XXX xxx xx Xxx. x XxxXx.

Xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx xxx x.x.xxxx xxxxxxxxx x.xxx,xx XXX. Xxx xxxx xxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx. Xxxxxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxx Xxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxx, xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxx xxx x. Xxxxxx xx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxx xx Xxx. x XxxXx.

xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx. Xxxxx xxx xxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx, xx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx. Xxxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxxxxx Xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxx xxxxx xx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxx. Xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx, xxxxx xxx xxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx.

Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxx xxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx:

• Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx: Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxx xx Xxxxxx xx xxxxx Xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx.
• Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx: Xxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxx xx.xxx XXX xxx Xxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxxx xxx. Xxxx xxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxxxxx, xxx XXxXxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xx Xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx.
• Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx: Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxx xx.xxx XXX xxx Xxxxxxxxxx.
• Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx: Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxx, xx xxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx x xxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx x xxxxx Xxxxxxxx xx Xxxxx xxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx xx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxx Xxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx. Xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xx Xxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxx xxx,xx XXX.
• Xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx: Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx. Xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxx xXxxxXxxx xxx x. Xxxxxxx, xxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxx. Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx. Xxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxx, xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xx xxxxxx xxx xxxxxx Xxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx.

2. Die Entscheidung des Bundesfinanzhofs: Kein Problem

Xxx xxxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxx x xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx x xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx:

Xx xxxxxx xxxx xxxxx xxxx Xxxxx. Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx XXXxXxxxxxx xxxx:

• Xxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxx x xx xxx Xxxxxxx x xxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xx, xx xxx xxxxx xx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx. Xxx!
• Xx xx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxx, xxx xx xxxx Xxxxxxxxx, xx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx. Xxxxxxx xxx xx xxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxx Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx. "Xx xxx xxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx, xxxx xxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxx."
• Xxxxxx xxxx xxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxx, xxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxx xxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx, xxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx, xxxx "xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxx".

Xxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx XxxxxxxxxxxxxXxxxxxxxx xx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxx xxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxx xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx, xx xxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xXxx. x Xxx. x XXx. Xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxx Xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxx. Xxxxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx, xxx xx xxxx xxxxx xx xxxxx Xxxxx xxxxxxxx, xxxxx xxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx. Xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xx xxxxxx Xxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxx xx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx, xxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx.

Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxx XXXxXxxxxxx xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xXXXxXxxxxxxxx xxx xx.x.xxxx, XXxXx. xxxx XX X. xxxx:

• Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxx xx.xxx Xxxx xxxx
• Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx, x. X. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxxxxx Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx
• Xxx xxxxxxx Xxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxx xxx XxxxxxxxxxxxxXxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx xxxxxxx x.xxx Xxxx xxx xxx Xxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxx
• Xxxxx xxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxx
• Xxxxx xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx
• Xxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx Xxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx Xxxx xxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx
• Xxx xxxxxxx Xxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxxx xx Xxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxx xxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx

Xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxx XXXxXxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx, xx "xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxx." Xxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx Xxxx xXXXx x xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx x xxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xXXXx xxxxxx xxx, xx "xxxxxxx xxxxx xxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx".

XXXXX: Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxx xxx xx.x.xxxx xxx Xxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxx xxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xx.x.xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx....

3. Die Entscheidung des Bundesverfassungsgerichts: Keine Einwände

Xxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx, xxxx xxx XXXxXxxxxxx xxx Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx. Xxxx xxxx. Xxxx xxxx xxxxxx xx xxxxxx: Xxx Xxxxxxx, xxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx Xxxxx xxxxxx, xxx Xxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xXxxxxxx Xxxxxx.

Xxxxx xxxx Xxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx XXXxXxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx x xxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx.

Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxx, xxxxx xxx xxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxx xxxx:

"Xx xxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxxx, xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx. Xxx xxxxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxxxx xxx Xxx xxx Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx xx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx.

Xxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxx, xxxxxx Xxxxxx xx xxxxx xxx xxxx xxxxx. Xxxxx xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx, xxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx, xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxx, xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx.

Xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxx, xxxxx xxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx. Xx xxx xxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xx Xxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx. Xxxxx xxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx.

Xxxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx, xxxxx xx xxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx Xxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx, xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxx. Xxxxxx xxxx xx Xxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx, xxxxxx xx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxxxxx Xxxxx xx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxx. Xxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxx, xxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx."

Xx Xxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xx xxx XX xXXXxXxxxxxxxx xxx x.x.xxxx, XXxXx. xxxx X X. xxxx.

Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxx xxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxx, xxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx. Xxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxx Xxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxx, xx xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxx! Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xx Xxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xXXXxXxxxxxxxx xxx xx.xx.xxxxx.

4. Die Entscheidung des EGMR: Beschwerde unzulässig

Xxx Xxxxxxx, xxx xx Xxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx Xxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxx xxx, xxx Xxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxx xXXXXx xxxxxxxxxxx.

Xxx Xxxxxxx x xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx x xxxxx xxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx "Xxxxx xxx xxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx" xXxx. x XXXXx xxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx "Xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx" xXxx. x xxx x. Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx XXXXx xx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx "Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx" xXxx. xx XXXXx xxxxx Xxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xXxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx Xxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xXxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx.

XXXXXXX: Xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx XXXX xxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxx. Xxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxx "xx Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxx" xx xxxxxxxxxxx. X.X. xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxx xxxx "Xxxxxxxxxxxxx". Xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx. Xxx xxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxx "Xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxx" xxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx. Xx xxxx xxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxx Xxxx xx Xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx, xxx xxxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxx. Xxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxx, xxx xxx xxxxxxxxx. Xxxxxx xxxxx xxx xxxx xxxxxxx xx xxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx: Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx.
Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx: Xxx XxXX xxx Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxx, xxx XXXX Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx.
x Xxx XxXX xxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx XXxXxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx, xxxx xxx XXxXxxxx xx xxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxx Xxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxx. Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx, xxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxx, xxxx xxx Xxxxx xxx XX xxxx Xxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxx.
x Xxx XXXX xxx xx xxxxxxxxxxx, xxxx xxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx. Xxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxxxx Xxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxx Xxxxxx xxxxxx. Xxx XXXX xxx xxx xxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx, xx xxx Xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxx.

Zum Einspruch gegen Verfahren vor dem Europäischen Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte

Xxxx Xxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxx XXXX xxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx. Xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxx xxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxx, xxxx "xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx, xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxx" xxxx. Xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xx xxx Xxx. x Xxxx x XXx. Xxxxxxxx xxx, xx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx xxx "Xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx" xxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx, xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xx xxxxxx.

• Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xx, xxxx xx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx xx xxx Xxx. x Xxxx x XX xxx XXXX xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxx xXXX Xxxxxxxxx xxx xx.x.xxxx, X xxxx Xx.
• Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxx xx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx, xxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxx XXXX xxxx Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xXX Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xx.xx.xxxx, x X xxxxxxx. Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xXXXxXxxxxxxxx xxx xx.x.xxxx, X X xxxxxxx. Xxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxx XX Xxxxx xXxxxxxx xxx x.x.xxxx, x X xxxxxxx xxx x X xxxxxxx, XXX xxxx X. xxxxx.
• Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx xxx "XxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxXxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx" xxx xx.x.xxxx xx Xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxx xxxx "Xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx" xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xx xxx Xxx. x Xxxx x XX xxxxxxxx xxxx. Xxxx xxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx, xxxx xxx xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx "Xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx" xxxxxxx xxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxx "Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxx". Xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xx xxxx xxxxxxxxx xx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx. Xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxx, xxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx xxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxx xxxxx, xxxxxxx xxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxx.

XXXXXXXXX: Xxxxxxxx Xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx, xxxxxxx Xxx Xxxxx Xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx xx xxx Xxx. x Xxxx x XX xXxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx. Xx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx, xxxxxxxxx xx xxxx, xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxxx "xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx" xxxxxxx xx xxx Xxx. x Xxxx x XX xXxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxx.

5. Die gesetzliche Grundlage

§ 12 AbgG - Amtsausstattung

xxx Xxx Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx.

xxx Xxx Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx

x. Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxx,

x. Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xx Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx,

x. Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxx xx Xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xx xxx xxxx xx xxx xx xxx

x. xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx xxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx xXxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx.x, xxx xxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxx xxxx.

Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx x. Xxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxx xxx xx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxx xxxx.

xxx Xxx Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxx, xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx. Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx. Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxx Xxxxxx xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx. Xxxx Xxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxx. Xx xxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx.

xxx Xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx

x. xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx xx Xxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx,

x. xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xx xx,

x. xxx Xxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx,

x. xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx

x. xxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx.

Xxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxx xxxx.

xxx Xxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx x.xxx Xxxx, xxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxx Xxxx.

xxx Xxx Xxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx xxx Xxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxx xxxxx, xxxxxxx xxxx xx xx xxx Xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx.